Hans Küng Lobs (another) Stupid-Grenade at the Pope

In my recent commentary about the crisis in the Legion of Christ (This Is No Time for Happy-Face Stickers), I said:

“Watch and see. You’ll soon notice certain people trying to use this scandal to malign Pope John Paul II (a long-time supporter of Fr. Maciel and the Legion), in a way similar to how some are right now attempting to exploit the recent SSPX Bishop Williamson Holocaust-debacle against Pope Benedict XVI.”

Here is an example of what I meant about how certain people make use of seemingly disparate issues to advance their agendas.

Fr. Hans Küng has oh-so-helpfully lobbed his very own “stupid-grenade” into the volatile  controversy (which is really a non-controversy) surrounding SSPX Bishop Williamson’s inane remarks about the Holocaust.

Who better at this moment to challenge Pope Benedict’s recent un-excommunication of four right-wing prelates than another 81-year-old?
The recent papal edict re-enfolding Bishop Richard Williamson, a British holocaust denier and misogynist, has offended Jews, set interfaith relations back fifty years, repudiated Vatican II’s own views, and left the 40 or so women recently excommunicated because of their illicit ordinations breathless with indignation.
It has also has provoked a sharp response in a German newspaper, one that is being quickly sent around the world on the internet. Its writer is the eminent professor of ecumenical theology at Tubingen University, where he continues to teach eager classes, although he’s not permitted by Rome to teach as an official Catholic theologian.
It is just one of the paradoxes in the story of modern Catholic thought, and in the personal life of Rev. Hans Kung. He is, and has been since 1954, a Catholic priest. When he travels, he stays in the various rectories of Catholic parishes, hearing the confessions of the faithful, as he told us in Toronto in 2002, “as much as I am able.”
With his easy charm, impressive intellect, and clipped accent, Hans Kung, ever a sharp thorn in the Vatican, strides once more onto the ecclesial stage. The world-known Swiss Roman Catholic priest and theologian, who served as a peritus or expert at the Council (1962-65), he shared this responsibility with his German colleague, Josef Ratzinger, then a progressive thinker. How their paths would diverge.
To get right to the point, Kung in his article on February 3, wished Barack Obama were Pope. “The mood in the church is oppressive, reforms are paralyzed, and the church in crisis,” he says. “Benedict is unteachable in matters of birth control and abortion, arrogant and without transparency and restrictive of freedom and human rights.”
For Kung, Benedict should act as Obama has done, declaring a crisis, identifying the problems, proclaiming a vision of hope, revitalizing ecumenism, gathering competent colleagues of either gender, and using the power of his executive office to issue decrees (unhindered by such institutions as a democratically-elected Congress or a Supreme Court.)
But no, “the Pope is reorienting himself backward, inspired by the ideal of the medieval church, looking toward the Council of 1870, not the one of 1965.” (read article)


  1. Neal Ford

    Definitely a candidate for upper class twit cleric of the year!Sadly, many people will be deceived by such people as Mr. Kung. (Sorry my computer doesn't do umlauts). Wstern civilization is being strangled by excessive democracy, or rather a misunderstanding of it, to wit, that everything is subject to a majority vote. Fortunately our pope doesn't harbour such delusions.I see things starting to unfold much as Michael O'Brien mused in his novel "Father Elijah: An Apocalypse",(http://www.ignatius.com/ViewProduct.aspx?SID=1&Product_ID=351&AFID=12&amp😉 where the church is under attack from within and without.

  2. Matt K

    I recently found one of his books in my Church library promoting all sorts of dissident and even heretical ideas. I took it out so I could learn more about his position, but I’m sad to say that I seem to have misplaced it. What a shame, it could be anywhere – in my closet, under a bed somewhere…or maybe it ended up going out with the trash. I guess I’ll never know.Thanks for confirming what I assumed about Hans Küng…he needs out prayers (but definitely not a spot on our bookshelves).

  3. Condottiere

    I bought a book about Islam from Küng, because he worked out the historical part in a good matter. But, dear Mr. Küng: as catholics we can’t accept Mohammed as a prophet (that’s what he say with his “Weltethos”) ;-)So: he even tries to transport his heretical ideas in nonfiction books. There are some fellows of Küng, who deny trinity, some even God. But the time for such “critical theology” (let’s say: stupid theology, because it’s a logical disaster) is running out. People are searching God, not an idea based on political correctness.Let’s pray for him, I think that would be the best! Despite the anticlerical part of our german mainstream media loves him and his buddies …Greetings from Germany.

  4. Dani

    What an idiot

  5. The Apostolate of Hannah's Tears

    As Fr. Corapi says get your weapons ready! Mine is my M-16 (Rosary)… I guess some people will always remain blinded but let us continue to pray for our enemies…Thanks for all you do Pat!!!

  6. Gabriel Bernal

    It is indeed sad when we see priests of the LORD teaching very grave errors. I pray for this fool and I hope our LORD will change his ways.Unfortunately, Fr. Kung is still stuck in the 60’s, he needs to grow up.

  7. clamhan_ruagh

    The so-called "catholic" university I went to was filled with aged hipsters doing a bad job of staying "cool" – obviously they stuffed a lot of Kung down our unwitting gullets.Here's Mike Healy's sharp take on the contrast between Kung and von Hildebrandt – http://insidecatholic.com/Joomla/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2207&Itemid=48&limit=1&limitstart=1Patrick – thank you for providing a solid, balanced voice in this week of hyteria.YKC

  8. Beautiful Oak Tree

    clamhan_ruagh wrote: “Patrick – thank you for providing a solid, balanced voice….”Please add: “à la Fox News!” Especially the ‘ad hominem’ comments!P.S. To create an ‘umlaut’on ‘u’, light up the ‘Num Lock’, press down ‘Alt’, and type ‘129’. (Küng) Do a Google search for ‘Accents (French+) Symbols.’

  9. Patrick Madrid

    Beautiful Oak, you’re being silly.

  10. Beautiful Oak Tree

    Patrick,I’m “being silly” about what? Your ‘Fox News blog’ or the ‘umlaut’? Or both?By the way, I’m truly sincere about both.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: